Loading articles...

EU, UK take contrasting messages from May's Brexit speech

Last Updated Jan 18, 2017 at 2:00 pm MDT

Malta's Prime Minister Joseph Muscat, whose country holds the European Union's presidency, addresses members of the European Parliament in Strasbourg, eastern France, Wednesday, Jan. 18, 2017. Antonio Tajani of the EPP Christian Democrat group was elected president of the European Parliament on Tuesday in a daylong polling series during which he defeated his socialist opponent. (AP Photo/Jean-Francois Badias)

LONDON – European Union leaders on Wednesday countered U.K. optimism about a smooth and mutually beneficial divorce between Britain and the EU, declaring that, no matter what British Prime Theresa May thinks, Britain can’t dictate the terms of the separation.

EU President Donald Tusk warned Britain that it will not be able to “pick-and-choose” the choicest bits of trade and immigration as both sides wade into the negotiations this spring. He said May’s Brexit speech on Tuesday, in which she outlined her plans for moving ahead with the divorce, was proof the EU’s united stance was working.

May acknowledged she would not be able to break the EU’s sacrosanct link between having people and goods move around freely, for she chose to emphasize Britain’s full control over its borders and laws as her top priorities.

Tusk said the concession “proves that the unified position of 27 member states on the indivisibility of the single market was finally understood and accepted by London” even before the negotiations start.

Such statements poured cold water on buoyant British praise for May’s aim for flexible and swift negotiations on top of a “bold and ambitious free trade agreement with the EU.”

Prime Minister Joseph Muscat of Malta, which holds the rotating EU presidency, insisted such a trade deal could only be negotiated after Britain leaves, which is expected in 2019.

EU Affairs Minister Ann Linde said May had made it “very clear that she wants a very hard Brexit” and anticipated difficult negotiations ahead.

And when British Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson heard about a reported comment from an aide to French President Francois Hollande that Britain should not expect a better trading relationship once it is out of the bloc, he let off steam.

“If Mr. Hollande wants to administer punishment beatings to anybody who chooses to escape, rather in the manner of some World War II movie, then I don’t think that that is the way forward,” Johnson said, in comments that raised hackles elsewhere.

Aiming to calm down tempers, EU Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker noted the EU was “not in a hostile mood” but added it will be tough to negotiate with a longtime EU member that now “will be seen as a third country.”

Uncertainty surrounded other aspects of May’s Brexit speech — including her promise of a vote for Britain’s Parliament on the deal struck with the EU.

May and Brexit Secretary David Davis both declined to answer outright when asked what would happen if lawmakers rejected it.

“They won’t vote it down,” Davis told the BBC. “This negotiation will succeed.”

It remains unclear, though, whether May can formally begin the process of leaving the EU without Parliament’s approval. Britain’s Supreme Court says it will give its highly anticipated judgment in a legal battle over Brexit on Jan 24.

Britain’s mostly Euroskeptic newspapers, meanwhile, seized on May’s suggestion Britain could hurt the EU economically if the bloc imposed a punitive deal.

The Times of London headline said “Give us fair deal or you’ll be crushed,” while the Daily Mirror summarized May’s message as “Give us a deal … or we’ll walk.”

European newspapers saw the Conservative prime minister’s speech as evidence that Britain was turning inwards.

Germany’s Die Welt ran the front-page headline “Little Britain.” In a nod to U.S. President-elect Donald Trump, Italy’s La Repubblica said: “London gets its wall.”


Casert reported from Brussels. David Keyton in Oslo contributed to this report.