Legal challenges against vaccine requirements unlikely to go far: lawyer
CALGARY – Legal experts anticipate a sharp increase in Albertans suing over proof of vaccination requirements, but say it’s unlikely they’ll actually win those challenges.
The question has come up now that the province released a website with frequently asked questions about proof of vaccination requirements, saying private businesses and municipalities’ decisions may be subject to legal challenges by individual Albertans.
RELATED: Alberta answers FAQs about vaccine passports with new web page
But Mount Royal University Justice Studies Instructor Ritesh Narayan says private businesses are allowed to require proof of vaccine.
Advertisement
“When I am setting my own policy, my own business policy that I only want patrons who are vaccinated, that’s on me. I’m not infringing upon anyone’s right. It’s my business. I have the right to keep myself and my staff safe,” Narayan explained.
He does, however, think businesses or governments imposing a vaccine requirement should expect some legal challenges.
RELATED:
-
Are mandatory vaccine passports impeding our Charter rights?
-
Could a vaccine passport help boost Alberta’s slow vaccination rates?
-
Air Canada’s strict new employee vaccine policy could set new workplace bar: experts
“A lot of people don’t quite understand the law. And they shouldn’t–they’re not lawyers,” he said.
“So there’s a lot of uncertainty about how the law works, which will present a lot of lawsuits and people taking matters to their human rights commissions.”
The game changes a little bit, though, if you have a case where you’re an employee already working at a business and then are forced to get a vaccine or faces getting fired.
Advertisement
Narayan says a legal challenge in that case could prove successful.